• Home
  • About
  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Sitemap
MENU

Resmanak

  • Home
  • Static Page
  • Menu
    • Drop Menu
    • Drop Menu
    • Drop Menu
    • Drop Menu
    • Drop Menu
  • Button
  • Menu
    • Drop Menu
    • Drop Menu
    • Drop Menu
    • Drop Menu
    • Drop Menu
  • Error
  • Type
  • Translate
Uncategories RedBlueAmerica: Is it time to replace the Electoral College? - Knoxville News Sentinel

RedBlueAmerica: Is it time to replace the Electoral College? - Knoxville News Sentinel

Unknown 3:16 PM

[ad_1]


Joel Mathis and Ben Boychuk, RedBlueAmerica
3:02 a.m. EST November 20, 2016

636145560007059961-Cartoon-1115.jpg

Popular vote vs. Electoral College(Photo: Cagle Cartoons)

For the second time in 16 years, it appears that the winning presidential candidate will lose the nationwide popular vote while winning office through the Electoral College. George W. Bush did it in 2000; Donald Trump, another Republican, has done it again in 2016. The Electoral College was designed by the Founders as part of the Constitution, but it’s come under increasing scrutiny — with critics suggesting it’s time to replace it with a system that lets voters directly elect the president.

What to do with the Electoral College? Keep it or boot it? Joel Mathis and Ben Boychuk, the RedBlueAmerica columnists, debate the issue.

JOEL MATHIS

Politics makes hypocrites of us all. If Hillary Clinton had won the presidency, there’s a decent chance I’d be calling for the preservation of the Electoral College. Instead, I’m arguing for its replacement.

Then again, the hypocrisy goes both ways. Donald Trump, back in 2012, argued against the Electoral College when he thought — mistakenly — that Mitt Romney had won the popular vote while losing the presidency. “The electoral college is a disaster for a democracy,” he tweeted back then.

Now? He calls it “genius.”

So here’s why we should replace the Electoral College: There is no other institution in American life where the loser of the popular vote wins the prize. None.

Defenders of the current setup point out that the Constitution has a number of “countermajoritarian” features — starting with the Bill of Rights, continuing on to the systems of checks and balances — that often restrain the will of American voters. That’s true! But here’s the key: Those features restrain the will of those voters. As a general rule, they don’t entirely usurp that will.

Here’s how Alexander Hamilton defended the Electoral College, writing in Federalist 68: “The process of election affords a moral certainty, that the office of President will never fall to the lot of any man who is not in an eminent degree endowed with the requisite qualifications. Talents for low intrigue, and the little arts of popularity, may alone suffice to elevate a man to the first honors in a single State; but it will require other talents, and a different kind of merit, to establish him in the esteem and confidence of the whole Union.”

With Trump on the precipice of taking the White House, it’s a “moral certainty” Hamilton was incorrect.

He was closer to the mark in Federalist 22, when he wrote “fundamental maxim of republican government … requires that the sense of the majority should prevail.”

There’s no way to say in confidence that the sense of the majority has prevailed in this election. It’s time to get rid of the Electoral College.

BEN BOYCHUK

Sixteen years after the Bush-Gore debacle of 2000, we still are essentially a 50-50 nation. In some ways, the divisions are deeper than they were way back when. Imagine how much worse things would be if we were the pure democracy too many Americans mistakenly believe we are.

America’s Founders did not want direct democracy. Because the United States is a federal republic now with 50 different states, the Electoral College ensures that “the sense of the majority should prevail” by guaranteeing the interests of smaller, less-populated states are not overwhelmed by the larger, more-populated ones.

The president-elect, by the way, is confused about the Electoral College. During his recent “60 Minutes” interview, Leslie Stahl asked Trump to reconcile his now-infamous 2012 tweet with his position now. “I’m not going to change my mind just because I won,” he said. “But I would rather see it where you went with simple votes. You know, you get 100 million votes and somebody else gets 90 million votes and you win.”

He acknowledged, however, that the Electoral College “brings all the states into play … and there’s something very good about that.”

What’s good is that the outcome reflects the geographic and political diversity of a republic of nearly 325 million people.

As Hillsdale College President Larry Arnn explained in the Wall Street Journal the other day, the Electoral College “helps establish the ground upon which the American people must talk with each other, while ensuring that they are not ruled as colonies from a bunch of blue capitals, nor from a bunch of red ones.”

Fact is, Hillary Clinton owes her popular vote margin entirely to cerulean blue California, a state that is at once the sixth-largest economy on the planet and home to roughly one-third of the nation’s welfare recipients.

Another fun fact: About one-third of the Democrats’ representation in the U.S. House of Representatives comes from just three states: New York, Massachusetts and the aforementioned Golden State. Get the picture?

Abolish the Electoral College to enshrine a national popular vote, and the denizens of Los Angeles, Boston, and Manhattan’s five boroughs would decide the presidency forevermore. And you really don’t want that.

Joel Mathis is an award-winning writer in Kansas. Ben Boychuk is managing editor of American Greatness. Reach them at joelmmathis@gmail.com, bboychuk3@att.net, or www.facebook.com/benandjoel

Read or Share this story: http://knoxne.ws/2fHh6Cf


[ad_2]

Share this

Share on FacebookTweet on TwitterPlus on Google+

Related Posts

  • Tech giants outspend banks in US lobbying - Engadget
  • Jabra Sport Pulse Wireless Special Edition review - Digital Trends
  • Michael Dell Sees 'Enormous Opportunity' in Tech
  • Texas Tech Faces Daunting Task In Sooners
  • Artificial intelligence will change the 'course of our species': Top Goldman tech banker - CNBC
  • How Donald Trump Hacked the Politics of Foreign Policy - New York Times
Tech Q&A: Boosting your cell signal, saving precious voicemails
3 Things Jeff Sessions Doesn't Understand About Tech - Forbes


EmoticonEmoticon

:)
:(
=(
^_^
:D
=D
=)D
|o|
@@,
;)
:-bd
:-d
:p
:ng
:lv
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)
  • Popular
  • Label
  • Arsip

Popular

  • Community workers fill gaps in health care
    [ad_1] She visits people like Jessica Gonzalez who went blind at the age of 22 because of uncontrolled Type 1 diabetes. Now 33, Gonzalez has...
  • With Tom Hanks Aboard, 'SNL' Parodies Final Presidential Debate - New York Times
    With Tom Hanks Aboard, 'SNL' Parodies Final Presidential Debate - New York Times
    [ad_1] Photo Tom Hanks portrayed Chris Wallace as moderator of the third presidential debate on a “Saturday Night Live” sketch last week...
  • Apple revamps MacBook Pros with new keyboard tech
    [ad_1] Apple on Thursday announced major updates to its MacBook Pro computer line, unveiling a dynamic new keyboard feature called the...
  • Tim Tebow discusses RNC speech invitation, possible future in politics
    [ad_1] Former Heisman Trophy-winning quarterback Tim Tebow said Tuesday that he would consider a future in politics, telling Fox News...
  • Dinosaur Rise More Gradual Than Previously Thought, Fossils Show - Tech Times
    [ad_1] Dinosaurs  never had a rapid evolution and they evolved slowly. This notion goes against previous theories that talk about a sudden s...
  • How Stoners Are Getting High (Tech)
    How Stoners Are Getting High (Tech)
    [ad_1] Michael Bourque was 45 years old the first time he smoked weed. A natural doctor recommended he look for some cannabis on Craigslist ...
  • Climate Change Will Have The Mediterranean Producing Unprecedented Ecosystems For The Last 10,000 Years
    [ad_1] Global warming  raises more and more concerns by the day, and the future of our climate is subjected to scientific theories and model...
  • Audiostrasse Science Tech Grooves sample pack at Loopmasters
    [ad_1] Loopmasters has released Science Tech Grooves , a sample pack by Audiostrasse featuring a collection of drum loops, pads, bass, synt...
  • Alaska's Novel Plan to Cut Health Premium Costs - Wall Street Journal
    [ad_1] Nov. 22, 2016 9:42 a.m. ET ANCHORAGE, Alaska—Health-insurance premiums for individuals in Alaska have been soaring almost ...
  • 7 Very Simple Tips For Healthy Living When You Are On A Tight ... - Huffington Post
    [ad_1] People with a limited budget are often concerned about the potential costs of making changes in their life that will improve their ov...

Label

  • Alcohol
  • Alcohol Training Class
  • Certification
  • Class
  • Intrahepatic
  • Investment
  • Investment Tips
  • Nugget Ayam
  • Nyc
  • Portosystemic
  • Resep Masakan
  • Resep Nasi Goreng
  • Shunt
  • Tips
  • Tips Certification Nyc
  • Tips Transjugular Intrahepatic Portosystemic Shunt
  • Training
  • Transjugular

Arsip

  • ▼  2016 (701)
    • ►  December (53)
    • ▼  November (432)
      • Keeping Up With The Kardashians is STILL filming d...
      • The biggest challenge to diversifying tech talent ...
      • Fidel Castro's ashes begin final journey across Cu...
      • Bella Thorne, Post Tyler Posey Breakup, Takes to H...
      • The Depressing Toyota Of The Future May Suggest An...
      • Tech Under Trump - WNYC
      • Eight months pregnant woman and unborn daughter ki...
      • 'Ronnie O'Sullivan should know better': World Snoo...
      • At least five dead after tornadoes rip through Sou...
      • Deep tech ascent: Europe's emerging digital indust...
      • Trump to Announce Carrier Plant Will Keep Jobs in ...
      • Miami Neighborhood Gets a High-Tech Makeover
      • From enemies to potential allies: How the Trump-Ro...
      • An ocean of water is found 620 miles below Earth's...
      • Aging with grace: Tips for good health after 40 - ...
      • Tech tries to get Trump's ear after shunning him d...
      • 'People were basically running for their lives': A...
      • Children better protected in sport than ever, says...
      • Trump names anti-Obamacare congressman Tom Price h...
      • Tech Talk: Get on the hi-tech bus
      • Cheryl keeps mum on pregnancy rumours
      • The Best 'Cyber Week' Deals On Clothes, Tech, Trav...
      • Desperate scenes in Syria attack aftermath filmed ...
      • How I Use Facebook Groups To Grow My Business - Fa...
      • Home Prices Recover Ground Lost During Bust - Wall...
      • 5 Great Tech And Engineering Internships For 2017 ...
      • Big Earthquakes Occur Where Faults Are Mostly Flat...
      • Our Profiteering Health Insurance Industry: Should...
      • Suspect Is Killed in Attack at Ohio State Universi...
      • Brexit and Trump could be good news for Canada's t...
      • Spice Girls' Emma Bunton confirms leaked GEM singl...
      • More people are applying for UK tech visas post-Br...
      • AT&T to launch new DirecTV Now service Nov. 30 - U...
      • Sadiq Khan has appointed a business advisory board...
      • Syria conflict: Rebels lose third of east Aleppo t...
      • 5 tech gifts you should definitely avoid this holi...
      • Energy Firms Step Up Business Investment - Wall St...
      • The ten things Australia needs to do to improve he...
      • Barry Bennell victim David Lean told police but 'n...
      • Should tech companies mimic Trump's marketing?
      • Honey G's X Factor performance is highjacked by pr...
      • 7 tech innovations of 2016 - USA TODAY
      • Cubans to throng Revolution Square in mourning for...
      • Tesla is entering the solar business at a terrible...
      • Syrian army Aleppo advance displaces thousands - F...
      • Tech Q&A: Hide online shopping purchases during th...
      • Trump, and Great Business Ideas for America
      • HEALTH NOTES: Most people still use A&E services o...
      • Box Office: 'Moana' Scores Huge $81M Thanksgiving ...
      • Chinese Tech Giant Huawei's Latest Smartphone Face...
      • Nick Cannon stands by his statements that Planned ...
      • Virginia Tech bludgeons Virginia 52-10 for 13th co...
      • Competing groups are trying to define the Dakota A...
      • Theresa May carries on Labour's business pay crack...
      • Michael Gove Renews Attack On 'Expert' Economists,...
      • Virginia Tech football thumps rival Virginia for 1...
      • Trump, and Great Business Ideas for America - New ...
      • Pregnant women and new mums in mental health fundi...
      • Crewe Alexandra to launch independent review into ...
      • Losses linger for Georgia, Georgia Tech fans
      • Tom Jones sports a tanned complexion as he dons a ...
      • Startup skills from Microsoft? How the tech giant ...
      • 'We've travelled 8,000 miles to see our anorexic d...
      • Drawing on Personal Experience, Women in Small Bus...
      • Kanye West Songs Remixed: Listen to 10 of the Best...
      • Tech Was Supposed to Crash in 2016. It Got Real In...
      • At Mercedes, Racing Is ‘Business on Steroids’
      • Many in Florida Count on Obama’s Health Law, Even ...
      • SAPD: Good Samaritan fatally shot outside Northwes...
      • 4 Deal-Bait Stocks for Big Tech Names to Snap Up -...
      • China to develop leisure sport sector to $130 bill...
      • Chinese tech firm LeEco uses Black Friday to intro...
      • Why should women have to pay the price for 'safety...
      • Best of the week: 'She Loves Me,' 'Black Nativity,...
      • Trump turns to Washington lawyer to navigate legal...
      • Game day: Georgia vs. Georgia Tech
      • Stripe, the US fintech firm founded by two Irish b...
      • Being popular is GOOD for your health: Climbing th...
      • S Korea braces for 'largest' protests against pres...
      • Tech Tent: The promise and perils of data
      • NBC's F1 racing team dishes on sport in Ridgefield...
      • 5 things 'The Brady Bunch' taught me about tech an...
      • Top scientist who discovered Litvinenko poison 'st...
      • Entertainment One Ltd (ETO) Earns “Hold” Rating fr...
      • Russian propaganda effort helped spread 'fake news...
      • Sous-vide startup wants to take the tech-industry'...
      • Want to avoid the mall craze? Small Business Satur...
      • Health Canada names team to review cases of Manito...
      • Trump Allies Raise Doubts About Mitt Romney Leadin...
      • Universities' AI Talent Poached by Tech Giants - W...
      • Reel Named to International Journal of Sport and E...
      • Bears hope Arlington site will help them right shi...
      • Colombia and FARC Sign New Peace Deal, This Time S...
      • Bella Thorne and sister Dani strip down to their u...
      • Donald Trump's national security chief 'took money...
      • The skateboarding helium robot and other tech news
      • Best and brightest businesspeople honored at Asia ...
      • The best and worst health news of 2016
      • Skyscanner sold to China travel firm Ctrip in £1.4...
      • Baig's best tech picks from a ho-hum 2016
    • ►  October (214)
    • ►  September (2)
  • ►  2011 (5)
    • ►  January (5)

Recent Comments

  • simplelife
    simplelifeInteresting stuff to read. Keep it up.sy…
Copyright © 2015 Resmanak - Template by Arlina Design - Sponsored by Caramenghilangkanmembuat | Distributed By Gooyaabi Templates